Chisel recommendations?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • LinuxRandal
    replied
    Might have better luck with estate sales, or look for garage sales from older people (back before so many imports). With the WWII generation so much gone, it is getting harder to find those that did a lot without a lot of power tools.
    I do tend to find a one or two, common size thing, rather then sets, like we think we need now (spoiled).
    I have a few finds, for portable boxes, but at home the whole set things are Marples blue handled (before Irwin, and I wonder if the Footprint ones compare now) as paring chisels and Narex mortising chisels.

    Leave a comment:


  • cwsmith
    replied
    Funny, as I was just discussing 'garage sales' with the LOML this past week. Around here, it's nothing but junk. Our street has an annual 'yard sale'' in the beginning of July and the picking arn't much more than the purging of all the useless junk people bought over the last year or so. Last night we got our "Bed, Bath and Beyond" and "Christmas Tree Shops" sales flyers and I said that more and more they just seem to be catering to folks who need to shop everyday... next year we'll see all that stuff at the Garage sales.

    We had a store in the area that sold 'estate sale' stuff. The fellow who owned the shop traveled around buying up such items and a couple of years ago I found a very nice Stanley plane for $6. It was made during the WWII, lacking any brass. It was in very nice condition and required only a little clean up. Along with it I purchased nice Stanley #78 and very nice Jewler's saw.

    I had a nice chat with the fellow and he told me it was getting harder and harder to stay in business as very few people have any clue as to what to do with any hand tools anymore. He told me "a few months ago I dumped a really nice Shop-Smith because I simply couldn't get rid of it" He sold it for $150. Unfortunately the guy had a heart attack and passed away a few months later. I was glad that I had had the chance to converse with him when I did.

    CWS
    Last edited by cwsmith; 07-10-2015, 07:09 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • capncarl
    replied
    For some reason yard sales in our area have changed for a Saturday thing to Friday/Saturday sales with some starting Thursday. With this day change if Saturday is you only day to shop you don't have a chance for fhe flea market and eBay re-sellers.
    capncarl

    Leave a comment:


  • LCHIEN
    replied
    some guys get lucky at garage and estate sales, but there's not that many woodworkers with the discrimination and money to get top quality tools.
    So when ever I stop at one, it's usually slim pickings for any interesting tools and or electronics gear, if anything.
    I've had the hope based on gloats but I've stopped stopping at them because I think the odds are against me and its not yielding value worth the time.

    Leave a comment:


  • David D
    replied
    I don't frequent garage sales and the like as I should. The last "deal" that I was fortunate to find was an older Porter Cable 314 trim saw that I found on Craig's List. I got it for less than half of what they go for on eBay and it was well cared for to boot.

    Leave a comment:


  • poolhound
    replied
    Originally posted by thiggy
    I am surprised that no one mentioned estate/garage sales as a source of quality chisels. Of course, you have to cull out the homeowner grade tools, but some nice vintage ones are there for the picking from time-to-time.
    Good point. I always keep my eyes peeled on CL for such things but most of the chisels I see are the bashed up craftsman/stanley variety. I have found a few odd good ones but quality sets are hard to find.

    Leave a comment:


  • thiggy
    replied
    I am surprised that no one mentioned estate/garage sales as a source of quality chisels. Of course, you have to cull out the homeowner grade tools, but some nice vintage ones are there for the picking from time-to-time.

    Leave a comment:


  • poolhound
    replied
    Originally posted by jussi
    I really like my veritas PM-V11 but they are pretty spends especially if it's your first non-beater chisels. I initially got the Narex chisels and really like those. A lot of stores care them.
    I also have some Narex and they are a good option.

    Leave a comment:


  • vaking
    replied
    I use a german set made by MHG (Messershmitt). You can find them at Hartville tools and at Amazon.
    Very good chisels.

    Leave a comment:


  • David D
    replied
    Originally posted by durango dude
    I bought a starter set from Woodcraft a few years back.
    (currently sold as Wood River Utility Set) They're good but not great.

    Almost identical set is being sold by Peachtree Woodworking - so I'd hazard a guess
    that they're produced in the same factory.

    They don't keep their edge as well as better chisels.

    I think I'd go to Highland Woodworking and buy a Narex set.

    There's one catch - the Narex chisels are labeled in metric,
    so I'm not sure how well they cut standard width (joke)
    I suppose I should get a standard set AND a metric set so that I'm equipped to build European style cabinets! LOL

    I've decided to buy the Narex chisels from Lee Valley. I think they're made to Lee Valley specs and are Imperial sized anyway?
    Last edited by David D; 07-06-2015, 10:22 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • durango dude
    replied
    duplicate post
    Last edited by durango dude; 07-06-2015, 01:04 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • durango dude
    replied
    I bought a starter set from Woodcraft a few years back.
    (currently sold as Wood River Utility Set) They're good but not great.

    I can't really complain - they're $39 for the set, now ---- and I bought them on sale for $25.

    Almost identical set is being sold by Peachtree Woodworking - so I'd hazard a guess
    that they're produced in the same factory.

    They don't keep their edge as well as better chisels.

    I think I'd go to Highland Woodworking and buy a Narex set.

    There's one catch - the Narex chisels are labeled in metric,
    so I'm not sure how well they cut standard width (joke)
    Last edited by durango dude; 07-06-2015, 01:05 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Pappy
    replied
    I also have a set of the Sheffield Marple chisels as my main users. For rough work, or if I'm not sure what I may find buried in the wood, I have a set of old Stanleys. For finer work I have a set of Sorbys that the wife bought as a Christmas present several years ago.

    Leave a comment:


  • JimD
    replied
    My "good" chisels are footprint brand. I think the are still sold but I don't know that they are the same quality. I got mine about 20 years ago. I use a Work Sharp 3000 to sharpen them and knives. It uses sandpaper stuck to glass discs turned at a low speed. Pretty painless way to do it.

    Leave a comment:


  • David D
    replied
    It's good to hear another positive experience with the Narex chisels as I really like the price. The scary sharp sharpening method looks like the way to go for me as well. I like the granite idea, I will definitely use that. Thank you!

    Leave a comment:

Working...