Decent, affordable planes?
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
My planes are very cheap. I have never had a LN or Veritas, so I cannot compare to $250 planes though. I have a new Stanley #4 from Lowes (about $40), a new Buck Brothers #5 from Home Depot (about same money), and an old Bailey #6 bought used on Ebay for under $40 too. The old Bailey is probably the best of the bunch with very little efforts to restore. But all of them cut wood as expected and make all the right sounds in the process and that is all I care about.Alex VComment
-
Garage sales and flea markets are a good place to go. My mother is always at garage sales and I told her I was looking. She isn't good with specifics, so I told her what length (she knows what a plane is), and Stanley or Bedrock on it.
I got a call to go meet her at a garage sale, and ended up with a Stanley #5, #7, and a Sargent made Craftsman, for $25 total. A few weeks later, she was going on a trip, and planned on hitting some of the craft stores and flea markets. I told her I was looking for a block plane, and said it was about 6 or 7 inches long. She came back and said my birthday present was on the table, then asked me if it was any good. She found a #65 for $7.
Now, since I don't have anyone to show me how to tune them up locally, I did order a #4 (stanley) from Clint Jones. That way I had one done, to compare to.
You don't have to hit the sales, just know someone who does.She couldn't tell the difference between the escape pod, and the bathroom. We had to go back for her.........................Twice.Comment
-
Another good source is estate sales/auctions. Straight estate sales you have to hit early since, like garage sales, tools go fast. At estate auctions a lot of the bidders are dealers more interested in furniture, period decorative items, etc. that they can turn over quickly. 'Collectible' hand tools tend to go low.Don, aka Pappy,
Wise men talk because they have something to say,
Fools because they have to say something.
PlatoComment
-
Sarge and I both reviewed Anant Kamal planes. Mine is the 2nd post. We had similar experiences in some ways and different in some. Since our mileage varied, yours probably will too...
http://www.bt3central.com/showthread.php?t=38724Doug Kerfoot
"Sacrificial fence? Aren't they all?"
Smaller, Smarter Hardware Keyloggers
"BT310" coupon code = 10% for forum members
KeyLlama.comComment
-
It took over a year, but I finally found a really nice old Stanley for $17 a few months ago. I still have some work to do to fully restore and tune it, but it worked great right after a sharpening.The garage sales seem to be a pretty good source.Comment
-
You aren't kidding, I walked into one Saturday at 8:00 A.M. and a fellow was carrying out a box of planes, spokesheaves, chisels, and what looked like a bow saw... Nothing else of any interest to me was left...Another good source is estate sales/auctions. Straight estate sales you have to hit early since, like garage sales, tools go fast. At estate auctions a lot of the bidders are dealers more interested in furniture, period decorative items, etc. that they can turn over quickly. 'Collectible' hand tools tend to go low.Please like and subscribe to my YouTube channel. Please check out and subscribe to my Workshop Blog.Comment
-
The old planes are nice. You may have to spend a lot of time and effort to get them in working order, depending on the condition.
I spent quite a few hours this weekend on a Stanley-Bailey #3. I got it off of craigslist last month. Once I got all the nicks out of the blade, lapped & sharpened, then the surfaces cleaned & flattened it cut wonderfully.ErikComment
-
Yeah, stores around here really markup the prices on old planes. I've found some "OK" deals, but nothing fantastic...
If I had more time, I'd try getting into going to garage sales, but honestly I have no idea how to effeciently track them down. Probably for the best at the moment, as I have to focus on finding a renter for my duplex these days.Comment
-
FWIW, Craigslist has a pretty good listing of Garage sales. But honestly, Garage sales are popping up EVERYWHERE on nearly every weekend near me this year... Some good stuff going up too...Please like and subscribe to my YouTube channel. Please check out and subscribe to my Workshop Blog.Comment
-
Ditto, except go to Hock Tools and order one the Krenov iron & chipbreaker. For $50 + some scrap wood and sweat equity, cuts better than any of my old Baileys. I think Craftsman Studio sells them at a slight discount. The iron is a beefy 3/16" thick.Comment
-
I just drive to the grocery store and hit any that crop up on the way. If I know I will have time, I check out craigslist or the local papers for neighborhood sales or individual sales that specifically list tools that I care about.If I had more time, I'd try getting into going to garage sales, but honestly I have no idea how to effeciently track them down. Probably for the best at the moment, as I have to focus on finding a renter for my duplex these days.
Oh, once you find a plane, I found this guide to restoring it: http://foldingrule.blogspot.com/2007...t-removal.html (parts 2 and 3 in the list on the right)Comment
-
I haven't studied how to do it yet, but there is a way to get an RSS or other automated feed from CL.
I'm in a bind because with a kid in college and one in private school, I have neither the money for the fine hand planes, nor the time to look for rust to restore, so I've found making my own woodies the best compromise. Also, I'm in TX (North Central), which is **** for old WW tools, except maybe down in the German Hill Country, where Pappy seems to sweep the countryside clean of all rust:-)
The only efficient ways I've found to shop for vintage hand tools is Ebay, or, Walt Quadrato at Brass City Records (just google the name). Walt is awesome. You pay a bit more for his stuff, but you know it's good (or he'll tell you what it needs), and he's still WAY less than most vintage tool dealers on the net, plus he's a wealth of knowledge and will take time to share it with you.Comment
-
I know some of the plane gurus won't like it but I've been happy with my 2004 vintage Stanley No. 5 I got from Rockler..
I took it home.. flattened the sole. scary sharpened the iron and went to town with it..
Maybe I just got lucky or I don't have a clue what "Good" is
Yes I tuned up an old Tradseman plane too.. It gets tons of use.
Now when I get this Type 17 No 5 tuned up I'll have something to compare it too.
William's Law--
There is no mechanical problem so difficult that it
cannot be solved by brute strength and ignorance.Comment



Comment