HF DC 2HP

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Russianwolf
    Veteran Member
    • Jan 2004
    • 3152
    • Martinsburg, WV, USA.
    • One of them there Toy saws

    #31
    quote:Originally posted by wassaw998

    If you overpower the "trash can" cyclone, what you end up with is an empty trash can. He's saying, that using the 2 oversized bags w/lower plastic bag is providing so much air flow, that the trash can ends up being worthless as the stuff in it is getting sucked to the bag.

    ---------------------------------------------------------------
    Let me ad this, on a typical cyclone , you do not want anything getting past the cyclone. The idea is all the "stuff" swirls around in the cyclone and falls down into the collection unit and only air passes to the next stage , which typically would be a cart filter. An effecient cyclone would have everything hitting the collector under the cyclone, and nothing hitting the collector under the cart filter and thus the cart filter would have a very very long shelf live and cloging and what not would be of no real concern. The trash can jobs are really not gona catch the small dust, but, they can stop the bigger stuff from passing thru and also help save the impellor from collisions (and I'd suspect, were you to have a cart filter and not a bag, the trash can job would perhaps help save your cart from collisions which could tear it). However, as he pointed out, when you get your system running with a lot of CFM, the trash can jobs typically just flat out fail (they become a full pass thru unit). I suspect were one handy with sheet metal they could form a more proper cyclone in place of the trash can and put that up front and maybe bring back the purpose.
    Actually, someone is already marketing an item that is closer to a cyclone than the trash can separator, but still is hooked to the DC. I'll try to find it.
    Mike
    Lakota's Dad

    If at first you don't succeed, deny you were trying in the first place.

    Comment

    • LinuxRandal
      Veteran Member
      • Feb 2005
      • 4890
      • Independence, MO, USA.
      • bt3100

      #32


      [/quote]Actually, someone is already marketing an item that is closer to a cyclone than the trash can separator, but still is hooked to the DC. I'll try to find it.
      [/quote]

      I think the one your talking about is sold on ebay all the time for $169.00!
      She couldn't tell the difference between the escape pod, and the bathroom. We had to go back for her.........................Twice.

      Comment

      • Russianwolf
        Veteran Member
        • Jan 2004
        • 3152
        • Martinsburg, WV, USA.
        • One of them there Toy saws

        #33
        http://cgi.ebay.com/Cyclone-Separato...QQcmdZViewItem

        here's the one from ebay, but I think I have seen some advertised in the magazines also. If they work as well as advertised, $200 isn't bad, IF.
        Mike
        Lakota's Dad

        If at first you don't succeed, deny you were trying in the first place.

        Comment

        • Jeffrey Schronce
          Veteran Member
          • Nov 2005
          • 3822
          • York, PA, USA.
          • 22124

          #34
          $130 HF DC
          $100 Wynn Filter
          $200 Ebay Cyclone

          $430 for pieced together DC

          or

          $495.00 Penn State Tempest 2 HP Cyclone with 1 micronbag

          Comment

          • dkhoward
            Senior Member
            • Dec 2003
            • 873
            • Lubbock, Texas, USA.
            • bt3000

            #35
            I gotta jump back in here. I have the HF DC with one of the rockler trashcan lids. With the stock setup (standard bags on the HF DC) and the Rockler lid on a 30 gal plastic barrel, I get little or no additional dust in the bags on the HF DC. I am about to order the Wynn filter conversion but as far as anything getting past the barrel, very little goes any further, even MDF dust. My system is plumbed with 4" S&D, flex tubing from the HF accessory kit and some additional fitting from HD to convert to 2.5" fittings.

            For most home shops, I cannot fathom a more efficient and cost effective system.
            Dennis K Howard
            www.geocities.com/dennishoward
            "An elephant is nothing more than a mouse built to government specifications." Robert A Heinlein

            Comment

            • Jeffrey Schronce
              Veteran Member
              • Nov 2005
              • 3822
              • York, PA, USA.
              • 22124

              #36
              quote:Originally posted by dkhoward

              I gotta jump back in here. I have the HF DC with one of the rockler trashcan lids. With the stock setup (standard bags on the HF DC) and the Rockler lid on a 30 gal plastic barrel, I get little or no additional dust in the bags on the HF DC. I am about to order the Wynn filter conversion but as far as anything getting past the barrel, very little goes any further, even MDF dust. My system is plumbed with 4" S&D, flex tubing from the HF accessory kit and some additional fitting from HD to convert to 2.5" fittings.

              For most home shops, I cannot fathom a more efficient and cost effective system.
              If little to no dust is getting to the bags, then why the Wynn filter? How long are your runs? Are they rather long and maybe that is why it is staying in trash can cyclone, while shorter runs result in more CFM reaching the can sucking them out?

              Comment

              • LCHIEN
                Super Moderator
                • Dec 2002
                • 22106
                • Katy, TX, USA.
                • BT3000 vintage 1999

                #37
                I think that those whose trash can separators are collecting a lot of cuttings, they are probably restricting the airflow . When the system is well plumbed to achieve as high an ariflow as possible I believe that the separator cans will be scoured clean.

                Maybe those whose separators are collecting are happy with the airflow which is achieving all they wanted it to do, so good for them.

                A so-called trashcan separator is not a true cyclone although it is similar. Real cyclones have carefully engineered diameter, height and taper/slope for a given flow rate in order to work properly and can drop out cuttings from the air stream at a selected design cut point for size and weight... That's usually what you are buying in those $700 systems.



                Loring in Katy, TX USA
                If your only tool is a hammer, you tend to treat all problems as if they were nails.
                BT3 FAQ - https://www.sawdustzone.org/forum/di...sked-questions

                Comment

                • LCHIEN
                  Super Moderator
                  • Dec 2002
                  • 22106
                  • Katy, TX, USA.
                  • BT3000 vintage 1999

                  #38
                  quote:Originally posted by Jeffrey Schronce

                  quote:Originally posted by dkhoward

                  I gotta jump back in here. I have the HF DC with one of the rockler trashcan lids. With the stock setup (standard bags on the HF DC) and the Rockler lid on a 30 gal plastic barrel, I get little or no additional dust in the bags on the HF DC. I am about to order the Wynn filter conversion but as far as anything getting past the barrel, very little goes any further, even MDF dust. My system is plumbed with 4" S&D, flex tubing from the HF accessory kit and some additional fitting from HD to convert to 2.5" fittings.

                  For most home shops, I cannot fathom a more efficient and cost effective system.
                  If little to no dust is getting to the bags, then why the Wynn filter? How long are your runs? Are they rather long and maybe that is why it is staying in trash can cyclone, while shorter runs result in more CFM reaching the can sucking them out?
                  if he is using the original bags which stop only 30 micron particles and bigger then those are the ones getting by the separator and being blown right back into the shop to breathe. A Wynn or other catridge filter with 1 or .5 micron cut will stop all the fine dust 1 - 30 microns that gets by the separator AND the old bags.
                  Loring in Katy, TX USA
                  If your only tool is a hammer, you tend to treat all problems as if they were nails.
                  BT3 FAQ - https://www.sawdustzone.org/forum/di...sked-questions

                  Comment

                  • LCHIEN
                    Super Moderator
                    • Dec 2002
                    • 22106
                    • Katy, TX, USA.
                    • BT3000 vintage 1999

                    #39
                    quote:Originally posted by 430752

                    can anyone tell us the shipping on this thing? the website faq says anything above $100 is 9.99 shipping, but if it has a certain asterisk thing, freight shipping surcharge of $40 is added. However, this dc unit doesn't have that asterisk thingy, but I can't believe its accurate.

                    I ask cuz with the 20% deal its like $127+ shipping, but if shipping is another $50, then its not such a good deal.

                    curt j.
                    don't remember but the shipping is reasonable, like $10 or maybe $5 with the coupons. I don't recall its being a factor in my costing; if it was $40 it would have been memorable. Most HF shipping is low or they wouldn't sell much by mail/internet order.
                    Loring in Katy, TX USA
                    If your only tool is a hammer, you tend to treat all problems as if they were nails.
                    BT3 FAQ - https://www.sawdustzone.org/forum/di...sked-questions

                    Comment

                    • ddamoore
                      Established Member
                      • Jun 2003
                      • 225
                      • Oklahoma City, OK, USA.
                      • Craftsman (Ridgid 3612 Clone)

                      #40
                      quote:Originally posted by LCHIEN

                      A so-called trashcan separator is not a true cyclone although it is similar. Real cyclones have carefully engineered diameter, height and taper/slope for a given flow rate in order to work properly and can drop out cuttings from the air stream at a selected design cut point for size and weight... That's usually what you are buying in those $700 systems.
                      Hear is my approach, which I posted sometime ago...I have about $180 bucks in it, primarily for the PSI blower & .5 micron bag. It is not as efficient as the $700 jobs, but works for my needs. Dennis



                      Dennis

                      "Everybody is ignorant, only on different subjects" - Will Rogers

                      Comment

                      • dkhoward
                        Senior Member
                        • Dec 2003
                        • 873
                        • Lubbock, Texas, USA.
                        • bt3000

                        #41
                        As Loring pointed out, the Wynn filter will capture those really fine particles that stay suspended for long periods of time and that even the best engineered cyclone usually fails to stop.

                        THe longest run on my system is about 16 ft and includes very few restictions. 4" flex line to all the tools. I do know that at the end of the longest run, the system will pick up a 1" x 1" cube of red oak from the floor, lift it to the overhead runs and deposit it soundly in the trashcan seperator. I don't think I have much airflow restriction.

                        I'm not saying it is the best or most efficient system available. I'm just saying that for the investment and time it took to put it together, it works well. ANy system has to be a balance between cost and efficiency. Depends on what you expect and what you want and how much you are willing to spend.
                        Dennis K Howard
                        www.geocities.com/dennishoward
                        "An elephant is nothing more than a mouse built to government specifications." Robert A Heinlein

                        Comment

                        • Russianwolf
                          Veteran Member
                          • Jan 2004
                          • 3152
                          • Martinsburg, WV, USA.
                          • One of them there Toy saws

                          #42
                          I can now confirm that the shipping is indeed $9.99 as mine has shipped today and they hit my card for $169.98.

                          Now I need some hose.
                          Mike
                          Lakota's Dad

                          If at first you don't succeed, deny you were trying in the first place.

                          Comment

                          • stewchi
                            Established Member
                            • Apr 2003
                            • 339
                            • Chattanooga, TN.

                            #43
                            I will chime it here , the Wynn filter gives you 10x or more surface area then the bags, at a much finer filtration. You can not filter down to .5 micron using bags without restricting airflow the bag would have to be huge. That’s the main advantage of the cartridge. Other advantages I have seen using mine, is that its not hard to clean (I use a leaf blower), I have never had it clog, and it is easier to keep the shop clean with it. I always made a mess with the bags, trying to empty them etc. With the CF there is no mess. The addition of a neutral vein helps the cyclone effect in the lower plastic bag so only the small stuff makes it up to the filter. I am also thinking about putting a box over my filter with an exhaust that I can either point at the overhead room filter (that I have not yet bought) or point it outside during nice weather.

                            Comment

                            • THyman
                              Established Member
                              • Feb 2005
                              • 315
                              • Atlanta, Georgia, USA

                              #44
                              quote:Originally posted by stewchi

                              I always made a mess with the bags, trying to empty them etc. With the CF there is no mess. The addition of a neutral vein helps the cyclone effect in the lower plastic bag so only the small stuff makes it up to the filter.
                              What is neutral vein and how did you install it?
                              War Eagle!

                              Comment

                              • JR
                                The Full Monte
                                • Feb 2004
                                • 5636
                                • Eugene, OR
                                • BT3000

                                #45
                                quote:Originally posted by THyman
                                What is neutral vein and how did you install it?
                                Uh-oh, you've done it now!

                                You might try a search for neutral vane. I'm pretty sure you'll get a hit or two.

                                JR
                                JR

                                Comment

                                Working...