Yeah, I agree on this one -- I think it implies that "it" is plural, and if you were going to use a plural form of "it" you'd probably just say "they" and end up with "their."
I think style guides are all over the board on this one. Some say always add it (some of those make exceptions for some biblical names -- e.g. "Jesus's" just doesn't look right), others say don't add it, and still others say only add it if it's one syllable and take it away if it doesn't sound right.
...and then there's the whole problem with French names -- do you write "Albert Camus' book" which looks like it should be spoken "Albert Ca-MOO book," or would you write "Albert Camus's book" which might be spoken "Alber Ca-MOOs book?"
I think style guides are all over the board on this one. Some say always add it (some of those make exceptions for some biblical names -- e.g. "Jesus's" just doesn't look right), others say don't add it, and still others say only add it if it's one syllable and take it away if it doesn't sound right.
...and then there's the whole problem with French names -- do you write "Albert Camus' book" which looks like it should be spoken "Albert Ca-MOO book," or would you write "Albert Camus's book" which might be spoken "Alber Ca-MOOs book?"
Comment