We Were Soldiers Once... and Young

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • JR
    The Full Monte
    • Feb 2004
    • 5636
    • Eugene, OR
    • BT3000

    #1

    We Were Soldiers Once... and Young

    I just finished reading this book, by Harold Moor and Joseph Galloway, last night. I was sobbing at the end.

    I'm a bit of a history buff, but don't read much military stuff, per se. This book, though, cought my eye in the airport book store. It is an incredibly well-written account of an incredibly brutal battle in Vietnam in November, 1965. The authors' technique of quoting several participants in an event, such as an airlift or a particular enemy contact, provides a depth of perspective you just don't get in most histories. Enemy commanders provide their stories, too.

    What made me so sad, though, was the stories presented by the loved ones of the fallen. This battle, in Ia Drang Valley, was one of the first after American combat troops arrived in theater. The nation was, apparently, unprepared for large numbers of American casualties. The wives and mothers were notified of the death of their soldier by telegram, delivered by a taxi driver.

    The 1/7 battalion commander's wife, the daughter of an infantry officer, took it upon herself to visit each of the 13 widows who were living at Ft. Benning. The 2/7 commander was a bachelor, so the wives of the XO and Sgt. Maj. stepped forward.

    I guess as the former dependant of a lifer this part touched a nerve. I can remember once when my mother stood in the kitchen crying. I must have been about five years old. The news had reported an advisor had been killed in action. This was 1958 and my father was one of about 150 Americans in Vietnam. He didn't die that day, but someone's father, or husband, or son, did. His family's life changed forever on that day.

    I just can't dry my eyes this morning.

    JR
    JR
  • DUD
    Veteran Member
    • Dec 2002
    • 3309
    • Jonesboro, Arkansas, USA.
    • Ryobi BT3000

    #2
    JR
    I know How You feel, I have days that I really have problems. I take medication, but they don't go away. God Bless, Bill
    5 OUT OF 4 PEOPLE DON'T UNDERSTAND FRACTIONS.

    Comment

    • gsmittle
      Veteran Member
      • Aug 2004
      • 2793
      • St. Louis, MO, USA.
      • BT 3100

      #3
      To all of you who serve/have served:

      Thank You!
      g.
      Smit

      "Be excellent to each other."
      Bill & Ted

      Comment

      • p8ntblr
        Senior Member
        • Jan 2007
        • 921
        • So Cal
        • Craftsman 22114

        #4
        Originally posted by gsmittle
        To all of you who serve/have served:

        Thank You!
        g.
        I second that.
        -Paul

        Comment

        • cabinetman
          Gone but not Forgotten RIP
          • Jun 2006
          • 15216
          • So. Florida
          • Delta

          #5
          Too much of an emotional subject for me to comment. I can't forget the tragedies, and have a heavy heart for those who had losses. As for reading material, I prefer upbeat lighter subjects.

          Comment

          • Hoover
            Veteran Member
            • Mar 2003
            • 1273
            • USA.

            #6
            The movie "We Were Soldiers" starring Mel Gibson as the Battalion commander, was released a few years back and has been aired on television several times.
            I try to watch each time it comes on. The scenes where the Major's wife took on the job of hand delivering the telegrams was difficult to watch.
            I haven't read the book, but what JR has commented on seems that the movie was faithful to the book.
            As a veteran of the US Army '69 to '72 I salute those who serve and have served, and say thank you.
            No good deed goes unpunished

            Comment

            • ragswl4
              Veteran Member
              • Jan 2007
              • 1559
              • Winchester, Ca
              • C-Man 22114

              #7
              My heart goes out to those who have lost loved ones. No greater sacrafice can be made. Bless those who serve and protect us today, they are the heroes of this generation and deserve the respect of our nation.

              Proud to have served.


              U.S. Navy, Retired
              1966-1986
              RAGS
              Raggy and Me in San Felipe
              sigpic

              Comment

              • gad5264
                Veteran Member
                • Aug 2005
                • 1407
                • Columbus, Ohio, USA
                • BT3000/BT3100NIB

                #8
                I have not served in the armed forces but my father(WW2), 3 uncles(WW2) and brother(VietNam) all did. I too stand and salute all who have served this great nation of ours. THANK YOU ALL!!!!
                Grant
                "GO Buckeyes"

                My projects: http://community.webshots.com/user/gad5264

                Comment

                • Bruce Cohen
                  Veteran Member
                  • May 2003
                  • 2698
                  • Nanuet, NY, USA.
                  • BT3100

                  #9
                  I got to agree wth Cab Man, I really have no desire to relive or remember all the years I spent in SE Asia.

                  Way too many ghosts and nightmares, still

                  Bruce
                  "Western civilization didn't make all men equal,
                  Samuel Colt did"

                  Comment

                  • tedkitch
                    Senior Member
                    • Jul 2006
                    • 646
                    • NE Suburbs, Chicago
                    • Ryobi BT3100 What else is there?

                    #10
                    I second the Thank-You's.

                    I got fired from a restaurant job when I was in high school for giving a uniformed GI a free meal. I offered to pay for the meal when the manager jumped down my throat and he told me that "those guys" don't deserve our respect or our thanks and that they were murderers. I called him every dirty word my 16 year old mind could muster and left. The GI waited in the parking and gave me a ride home. He had served in Vietnam and said that it felt good to have someone young stand up for him like that.

                    My father served in Vietnam and I can remember being a little guy and waking him up while he was sleeping and he would grab me with everything he had with a very crazed look in his eyes. I didn't do it too many times as it would freak me out. To this day he will not talk about what he did in Vietnam. I can't imagine what it would be like to have to carry that around for a lifetime.

                    God Bless every one of you for serving and again thanks,
                    Ted Kitch

                    Comment

                    • lcm1947
                      Veteran Member
                      • Sep 2004
                      • 1490
                      • Austin, Texas
                      • BT 3100-1

                      #11
                      Thanks guys. It's been years but always nice to hear somebody say thank you to me (us). I for one always have appreciated the few thank you's that I've gotten over the years and still do. Makes one feel kind of good and that's always a good feeling not to mention the smile that always touches my face when I hear one. Take care.
                      May you die and go to heaven before the Devil knows you're dead. My Best, Mac

                      Comment

                      Working...