NPR Reports Table Saw Safety

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • cwsmith
    Veteran Member
    • Dec 2005
    • 2812
    • NY Southern Tier, USA.
    • BT3100-1

    #1

    NPR Reports Table Saw Safety

    I just heard this a few minutes ago on NPR. I don't think their numbers are correct, but it certainly sounds like the problem is absolutely horrendous....40,000 accidents a year?

    Advocates Urge Lawmakers To Make Table Saws Safer : NPR


    CWS
    Think it Through Before You Do!
  • Pappy
    The Full Monte
    • Dec 2002
    • 10490
    • San Marcos, TX, USA.
    • BT3000 (x2)

    #2
    Looks like Gass is at it again, with some new 'buddies'.
    Don, aka Pappy,

    Wise men talk because they have something to say,
    Fools because they have to say something.
    Plato

    Comment

    • Black wallnut
      cycling to health
      • Jan 2003
      • 5513
      • Ellensburg, Wa, USA.
      • BT3k 1999

      #3
      Oh boy here we go again.
      Donate to my Tour de Cure


      marK in WA and Ryobi Fanatic Association State President ©

      Head servant of the forum

      ©

      Comment

      • pelligrini
        Veteran Member
        • Apr 2007
        • 4217
        • Fort Worth, TX
        • Craftsman 21829

        #4
        Jeese, another one sided article using sensational examples. Didn't mention anything about the carpenter not using allready available safety devices. I don't see how he could have got his injury if there were a guard in place.

        While I would like to see more manufacturers do more with making blade stopping tech available, it doesn't not need to be law.
        Erik

        Comment

        • Black wallnut
          cycling to health
          • Jan 2003
          • 5513
          • Ellensburg, Wa, USA.
          • BT3k 1999

          #5
          Yup NPR is now doing infomercials and spinning it as news.
          Donate to my Tour de Cure


          marK in WA and Ryobi Fanatic Association State President ©

          Head servant of the forum

          ©

          Comment

          • pelligrini
            Veteran Member
            • Apr 2007
            • 4217
            • Fort Worth, TX
            • Craftsman 21829

            #6
            This meeting with the CPSC and Sawstop doesn't seem too bad. http://www.cpsc.gov/LIBRARY/FOIA/mee...er03012011.pdf

            Commissioner Adler thanked the SawStop representatives for traveling to make the presentation and for their forthrightness in answering questions from him, his staff, and the attendees. He stated that he highly doubted the Commission would ever mandate a specific technology when writing a performance standard, nor was he interested in doing so. While the injury rates from table saws were of great concern to him, he stated he was personally opposed to granting any single individual or company a personal windfall via government regulation. He also stated that any Commission action would likely take the form of a performance standard that would explain what steps needed to be taken to make the product safer for consumers -and that hopefulJy there would be multiple paths to meet that standard.
            Erik

            Comment

            • dbhost
              Slow and steady
              • Apr 2008
              • 9570
              • League City, Texas
              • Ryobi BT3100

              #7
              It's NPR... Do I need to say more?
              Please like and subscribe to my YouTube channel. Please check out and subscribe to my Workshop Blog.

              Comment

              • natausch
                Established Member
                • Aug 2009
                • 436
                • Aurora, IL
                • BT3000 - 15A

                #8
                Maybe if our fair government wants to mandate SawStop technology they should first consider legislation that removes liability of employer, distributor or manufacturer if the user intentionally disables safety features.

                After all, if Glass is going to get his 8% off the top of total table saw sales as he originally pitched maybe we should make sure he isn't sued to the ends of the earth the first time someone disables sawstop and cuts his finger off.

                Comment

                • pelligrini
                  Veteran Member
                  • Apr 2007
                  • 4217
                  • Fort Worth, TX
                  • Craftsman 21829

                  #9
                  This is pretty interesting too: http://www.cpsc.gov/volstd/tablesaws/tablesaws.html

                  Most of the injury data is from a small sample done in 2001 in the petitions. I'm no statistician, but it looks like there could be a large margin of error. I haven't seen much content in the later survey analyzing the incorporation of riving knives into the standards either. There is more data in the later survey. The sample of respondent's narratives of incidents at the end of the 2007-2008 survey tells me a lot more than what the stats do.
                  Erik

                  Comment

                  • herb fellows
                    Veteran Member
                    • Apr 2007
                    • 1867
                    • New York City
                    • bt3100

                    #10
                    Putting government regulations aside for a minute....

                    The table saw manufacturers say that it would add $100 to the price of a saw, and that would be prohibitive in the case of a $100 saw.

                    While this seems convincing on the face of it, I have to wonder if you gave the buyer the option up front, which way would the buyer go?

                    If you posed the situation this way:

                    You can buy this saw for $100, but if your hand goes into the blade, you will likely sustain serious injury/amputation.

                    or;

                    You can buy this same saw for $200 and if your hand goes into the blade you will more than likely sustain little or no injury.

                    Granted, there are people who will try to save a buck, either because they are cheap or because they simply can't afford it.

                    I do think, however, that the vast majority of people would buy that $200 saw. I know I would.

                    What I'm thinking is that too many people are gettijng the hair raised on the back of their necks as soon as they hear the word 'government'. They are ready to throw the baby out with the bath water, as the saying goes.

                    You can argue that the government shouldn't be involved, but the idea remains as a solid investment in safety IMHO.
                    You don't need a parachute to skydive, you only need a parachute to skydive twice.

                    Comment

                    • herb fellows
                      Veteran Member
                      • Apr 2007
                      • 1867
                      • New York City
                      • bt3100

                      #11
                      Originally posted by pelligrini
                      Jeese, another one sided article using sensational examples. Didn't mention anything about the carpenter not using allready available safety devices. I don't see how he could have got his injury if there were a guard in place.

                      While I would like to see more manufacturers do more with making blade stopping tech available, it doesn't not need to be law.
                      In an ideal world, the guard would always be in place, but we all know there are operations that are impossible to do with the guard in place. So to be completely safe, nobody should attempt these operations, but in the real world, you know that isn't going to happen.
                      You don't need a parachute to skydive, you only need a parachute to skydive twice.

                      Comment

                      • tommyt654
                        Veteran Member
                        • Nov 2008
                        • 2334

                        #12
                        Thats all fine and dandy Herb , but a majority of the $100 saws will not be able to substain the power thats utilized in a safety device such as the 1 Gass has on his tablesaws. It would literally destroy the entire saw.However the newest safety device that in the works the Whirlwind will be able to be mounted to most available tablesaws and withstand the technology's use. Thats what Gass is so upset about, He's gonna lose out in the long run here and I'll be LMAO at him and his lawyer friends

                        Comment

                        • BigguyZ
                          Veteran Member
                          • Jul 2006
                          • 1818
                          • Minneapolis, MN
                          • Craftsman, older type w/ cast iron top

                          #13
                          I think I remember hearing that the SS technology would not work for a direct drive saw. The saws in the $100-$300 price range are direct drive. So if that's true, that means you would essentially remove the bottom end of the market and your entry point for any table saw would be your $500 saw + $100 for the SS tech. Fo you jump from a $100 entry point to a $600 entry point.

                          The thing I find funny, is that they state how long SS has been on the market. So? If the carpenter who got injured thought it was important, shouldn't it have been incumbent on the carpenter himself to buy the available SS enabled saw that's available? Essentially, he voted with his pocket book to NOT buy Gass' saw, and was hurt when he didn't follow safety rules. And now, he wants to take away everyone else's choice and mandate a new technology.

                          I really AM in the bubble here. I think that the technology is good. I think the technology SHOULD be on saw where it makes sense (maybe not every saw). However, I don't think that it's good to make a government required monopoly.

                          Originally posted by herb fellows
                          Putting government regulations aside for a minute....

                          The table saw manufacturers say that it would add $100 to the price of a saw, and that would be prohibitive in the case of a $100 saw.

                          While this seems convincing on the face of it, I have to wonder if you gave the buyer the option up front, which way would the buyer go?

                          If you posed the situation this way:

                          You can buy this saw for $100, but if your hand goes into the blade, you will likely sustain serious injury/amputation.

                          or;

                          You can buy this same saw for $200 and if your hand goes into the blade you will more than likely sustain little or no injury.

                          Granted, there are people who will try to save a buck, either because they are cheap or because they simply can't afford it.

                          I do think, however, that the vast majority of people would buy that $200 saw. I know I would.

                          What I'm thinking is that too many people are gettijng the hair raised on the back of their necks as soon as they hear the word 'government'. They are ready to throw the baby out with the bath water, as the saying goes.

                          You can argue that the government shouldn't be involved, but the idea remains as a solid investment in safety IMHO.

                          Comment

                          • tommyt654
                            Veteran Member
                            • Nov 2008
                            • 2334

                            #14
                            While I agree the technolgy is great,So is the whirlwind.After furthur research here's what I have found. Sally Greenburg is apparently another back-pocket advocate for Gass,Why? 1: Shes a fellow attorney that headed up the Women Bar Assoc. in Mass. 2: Interestingly enough thats where the Osario vs Ryobi case was started. 3: They do not say too much about Thulls injury other than the fact he was injured after reaching over the saw to catch a piece of wood he was cutting to keep it from falling off the back of the saw(easily avoidable with an extension table) 4: This guys just another Osario in my book, Too amateurish of a carpenter to know what he was doing, and handled the equipment improperly by having the guard removed in the 1st place. 5: Its easy to see Gass's intervention here, you just have to read between the lines

                            Comment

                            • Mr__Bill
                              Veteran Member
                              • May 2007
                              • 2096
                              • Tacoma, WA
                              • BT3000

                              #15
                              The bottom line is, "You Can't Fix Stupid". Even with SawStop technology people will find a way to defeat it to save money or time. As for Whirlwind, anyone who will go through the whole setup for it would also use the safety features that came with the saw. Whirlwind also seems to not allow for dados (or did I miss that?).

                              I think the SawStop approach that allows you to have a bare blade and still protect is the way the technology should progress. I do think that the expense of a SawStop activation must be overcome before it will be widely accepted and I am sure that someone will come up with a solution. (soon to be in Harbor Freight??)

                              I expect that soon you will need a rider on your insurance to cover dangerous tool use and that discounts will be given for safety technology. End result will be even more expensive for everyone as all involved take a profit.

                              Bill
                              happy with his BT3000

                              Comment

                              Working...