Recommend/What to look for in an impact driver?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • TheRic
    Veteran Member
    • Jun 2004
    • 1912
    • West Central Ohio
    • bt3100

    #16
    Originally posted by gsmittle
    BTDT. I feel for ya, brother--especially when you try to take those stripped screws out....

    g.
    I have found that my impact driver with a good bit on the end will take out stripped screw that other drills big name drills with bits could not!! It's how the impact driver works, compared to a drill. There really is very little comparison.

    As several people have said get an impact driver that matches the batteries that you already have. If you don't have any batteries, or don't care I would suggest the Ridgid. With it's Lifetime Warranty, including the batteries, I don't see how you can go wrong. I have the 18V one, thinking about getting a 14.4V also. My brother has a 14.4 B&D, he can drive screws thru wood with no trouble, break heads off of bolts etc. I don't think the B&D is better, I just think the 14.4V is plenty, and probably lighter.

    Someone asked about battery life. I think, have not actually done a comparison, the battery life on the Impact Driver seems to get me further. I think it's the way the impact driver works, compared to a drill.

    As for comparing them, I think there are differences, but both have there advantages in different situations. I would compare it to a NASCAR car and your family auto. If I was racing I would want the NASCAR car, the family car would get lapped so fast it wouldn't even be funny. If I was taking grandma to the grocery store I would want the family car (can you picture trying to get grandma thru the window ), once in side where would she sit, were do you put the groceries. Driving 20 miles down the road to work, both will get me there.
    Ric

    Plan for the worst, hope for the best!

    Comment

    • poolhound
      Veteran Member
      • Mar 2006
      • 3196
      • Phoenix, AZ
      • BT3100

      #17
      Originally posted by TheRic
      As for comparing them, If I was taking grandma to the grocery store I would want the family car (can you picture trying to get grandma thru the window ), once in side where would she sit, were do you put the groceries. .
      On Granny's lap of course.............................
      Jon

      Phoenix AZ - It's a dry heat
      ________________________________

      We all make mistakes and I should know I've made enough of them
      techzibits.com

      Comment

      • rnelson0
        Established Member
        • Feb 2008
        • 424
        • Midlothian, VA (Richmond)
        • Firestorm FS2500TS

        #18
        The Ryobi may have been abused by the contractor too, so that may be part of the reason for the wobble (although- lug nut removal with the Dewalt didn't damage it).
        Most definitely abuse, but probably not from the actual use. I've dropped my Ryobi hammer drill from the top of a 40 foot ladder (twice - one right after another!) and the darn thing still chugs along. There's a bit of wobble in it, but it hasn't caused any problems with screws stripping themselves out. The other drill that hasn't been dropped is just fine.

        The other contractor on that job with me had a dewalt that burned up about 20 minutes after I finished dropping my drill. He was provided a $200 estimate for repair. Now he uses Ryobi!

        Comment

        • jussi
          Veteran Member
          • Jan 2007
          • 2162

          #19
          Originally posted by balzac.thegreat
          I guess I should stick with my 19volt C-Man C3 line and get their impact driver. It's actually onsale right now for 69.99.

          http://www.sears.com/shc/s/p_10153_1...=impact+driver
          Is this for the bare tool only? no batteries/charger?
          I reject your reality and substitute my own.

          Comment

          • spankynmagic
            Forum Newbie
            • Mar 2008
            • 12
            • Richmond, VA
            • BT3100

            #20
            I have the Bosch. Lowes had it priced for $155 and it came with a free flashlight. They also had it priced for $179 two isles over...go figure. It came up as $155 at the checkout. I LOVE it. Small, light weight, long battery life, and it hasnt had a lick of trouble driving 3" screws thru 2x material.
            SpanKY

            Comment

            • jussi
              Veteran Member
              • Jan 2007
              • 2162

              #21
              Bosch for $140
              I reject your reality and substitute my own.

              Comment

              • balzac.thegreat
                Forum Newbie
                • Jan 2008
                • 77
                • Jersey City, NJ
                • Craftsman 21829

                #22
                Originally posted by jussi
                Is this for the bare tool only? no batteries/charger?
                Yeah...picked it up yesterday. It's only the tool. No battery, no charger. Perfect if you already have C3 system tools (which I do)

                Comment

                Working...