finish comparison question

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Wood_workur
    Veteran Member
    • Aug 2005
    • 1914
    • Ohio
    • Ryobi bt3100-1

    #1

    finish comparison question

    I'm looking at the water based finish comparison article in fine woodworking November/December 2006, and I have a question. they mention softer finished are more scratch resistant, so does that mean that if you want a scratch resistant finish you should look for one that is very soft as opposed to medium?
    Alex
  • cabinetman
    Gone but not Forgotten RIP
    • Jun 2006
    • 15216
    • So. Florida
    • Delta

    #2
    Originally posted by Wood_workur
    I'm looking at the water based finish comparison article in fine woodworking November/December 2006, and I have a question. they mention softer finished are more scratch resistant, so does that mean that if you want a scratch resistant finish you should look for one that is very soft as opposed to medium?

    I didn't read the article. Are you referring to "soft" and "medium" as related to "satin", "semi-gloss", and "gloss" type finishes.

    You might have misunderstood the reference. For water based polyurethane, and for that mater, oil based polyurethane, the gloss mix is usually the harder of the finishes. What they may have been referring to is that scratches might be less visible with a satin finish.

    But, since I didn't read the article, I could be rowing with one oar.
    .

    Comment

    • Wood_workur
      Veteran Member
      • Aug 2005
      • 1914
      • Ohio
      • Ryobi bt3100-1

      #3
      no, it didn't compare the sheens, just the hardness. the minwax fast drying poly was a very soft, and all the water based lacquers were a medium. It mentioned that softer=more durable but harder=easier to get a high gloss from.
      Alex

      Comment

      • JimD
        Veteran Member
        • Feb 2003
        • 4187
        • Lexington, SC.

        #4
        I am sure I read the article but not sure I remember it. Was this the article that labeled Resisthane the "best buy"?

        Oil based poly takes up to 30 days to reach full hardness. It is soft early but gets quite hard. Resisthane gets hard much quicker. It is not rated for floors but for furniture or cabinets, it is plenty durable. I think Resisthane is more durable initially but oil basd may be more durable after 30 days.

        Jim

        Comment

        • MilDoc

          #5
          "Soft" finishes are more elastic and can take pressure then reform (although scratch them hard enough and you will see it). (Think Jello, or even better, plain water). "Hard" finishes are brittle and show the marks from pressure since they can't reform. (Think glass)

          But when it comes to choosing a finish I consider not only that, but what will the finish be used on. If hot cups might be placed on it then heat resistance is more important. If it might be scratched a lot but not subject to heat (hopefully) then i look for a finish that can "deform," so the "softer" the better.

          It's always a trade off. No finish is perfect for all uses.

          Comment

          • Wood_workur
            Veteran Member
            • Aug 2005
            • 1914
            • Ohio
            • Ryobi bt3100-1

            #6
            Originally posted by MilDoc
            "Soft" finishes are more elastic and can take pressure then reform (although scratch them hard enough and you will see it). (Think Jello, or even better, plain water). "Hard" finishes are brittle and show the marks from pressure since they can't reform. (Think glass)

            But when it comes to choosing a finish I consider not only that, but what will the finish be used on. If hot cups might be placed on it then heat resistance is more important. If it might be scratched a lot but not subject to heat (hopefully) then i look for a finish that can "deform," so the "softer" the better.

            It's always a trade off. No finish is perfect for all uses.
            yea. this is musical instrument, so think large pieces of metal hitting it (drums and the hardware) and sweat resistance... so oil based poly seems like the best bet.

            and yes, this article rated resisthane the best value. (the best finish was like $40 a quart)
            Alex

            Comment

            Working...