Question for the docs

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • jonmulzer
    Senior Member
    • Dec 2007
    • 946
    • Indianapolis, IN

    #1

    Question for the docs

    I keep Vitamin C supplements and Vitamin C drops around for when I am sick and literally eat the drops like candy. Looking at the FDA RDAs on these I notice the supplements have 833% RDA and each drop is 100% of RDA. Is it feasible for someone to overdose on Vitamin C? I realize you can overdose on anything, including water and oxygen, but how much Vitamin C would it take to do damage, assuming your kidneys and liver are fully functioning of course. For those of us who do take supplemental Vitamin C, is there anything we need to be aware of?
    "A fine beer may be judged with just one sip, but it is better to be thoroughly sure"
  • Alex Franke
    Veteran Member
    • Feb 2007
    • 2641
    • Chapel Hill, NC
    • Ryobi BT3100

    #2
    I'm not a physician, but I actually did look that up a few weeks ago for myself and came up with this, which I bookmarked: http://www.emedicine.com/emerg/TOPIC638.HTM
    online at http://www.theFrankes.com
    while ( !( succeed = try() ) ) ;
    "Life is short, Art long, Occasion sudden and dangerous, Experience deceitful, and Judgment difficult." -Hippocrates

    Comment

    • MilDoc

      #3
      Nice rescource Alex. I printed that one out a while back for patients that asked.

      RE: Vitamin C: most common is nephrolithiasis, ie, renal stones. They hurt like !@#$ when passed, and drinking a LOT of fluids may not prevent their occurrence with large doses of Vitamin C. As the article mentions, can also effect the enamel in your teeth.

      BTW: there are numerous studies that show no benefit to large doses of Vitamin C for colds, etc. Why bother?

      OTOH, zinc lozenges have been shown to reduce the length of time and severity of simple colds, although not by very much.

      Comment

      • germdoc
        Veteran Member
        • Nov 2003
        • 3567
        • Omaha, NE
        • BT3000--the gray ghost

        #4
        Other than enriching the coffers of the vitamin manufacturers, you're not doing too much. If you eat a well-balanced diet and aren't menstruating you really don't need vitamins.

        I used to recommend vitamin E for my patients to prevent heart disease, etc., until studies showed it was actually killing more patients than it cured. So call me a vitamin and supplement skeptic.
        Jeff


        “Doctors are men who prescribe medicines of which they know little, to cure diseases of which they know less, in human beings of whom they know nothing”--Voltaire

        Comment

        • MilDoc

          #5
          Originally posted by germdoc
          If you eat a well-balanced diet ...
          And there is the rub. How many Americans eat a nice, well balanced diet?

          IMHO a simple daily vitamin supplement should be recommended for everyone, kids included. Especially those that get PopTarts for breakfast, mac & cheese for lunch, and Chicken Nuggets for supper.

          Comment

          Working...